I would put The Rolling Stones in the top 10 with the Beatles and Pink Floyd number 1 and 2. Music is feel and melody and how you put chords into a musical language or form. Emotional impact from lyrical content is not actually musical content. Artists like Captain Beefheart, The Velvet Underground, and Frank Zappa on the whole lack those qualities.
Let me see Revolver more influential and innovative than Blonde on Blonde. Abbey Road better to most people's ears than Trout Mask Replica. Magical Mystery Tour just as good as the Doors first album. Sgt Pepper is just as good as Pink Floyd's first album. A Hard Day's Night made the Byrd's go folk rock. Rubber Soul is much more listenable than Dylan Highway 61. The Beatles were the 60's not to have one of there albums is missing the point really.
Dylan is just a terrible singer no wonder why his albums never sold that well and other artists made superior versions of his songs. On the other hand Elvis never wrote his songs but was a great singer hence you have the two most overrated artists of all time, artists who were good at one thing.
I have to say your list is again is anti Beatle and you have no arguement to say these albums are overrated. For an album to be overrated to me is to have no impact on musicians and on the public. Clearly all of the Beatles albums you listed as overrated had a clear impact on the industry of rock music, the public and most of all the musicians. As for you knocking the Beatles as musicians you are lost, Paul McCartney is one of the most versatile rock musicians of all times, Lennon played at least three instruments and Harrison played the sitar, mellotron, slide guitar and 12 string guitar all effectively and made huge impact on popularizng those intruments in rock music. As songwriters they were no greater hitsmakers in rock music than the Beatles and the vocal harmonies on Abbey Road are amongst the most coppied in rock music. The Beatles wanted to be big and what they became is the most influential act ever in rock music.
Are you serious Captain Beefhart and Nico over John Lennnon as a vocalist I don't mean to be nasty. Have you heard of songs like A Day in the Life or the primal vocals of Yer Blues.
I would put The Rolling Stones in the top 10 with the Beatles and Pink Floyd number 1 and 2. Music is feel and melody and how you put chords into a musical language or form. Emotional impact from lyrical content is not actually musical content. Artists like Captain Beefheart, The Velvet Underground, and Frank Zappa on the whole lack those qualities.
Let me see Revolver more influential and innovative than Blonde on Blonde. Abbey Road better to most people's ears than Trout Mask Replica. Magical Mystery Tour just as good as the Doors first album. Sgt Pepper is just as good as Pink Floyd's first album. A Hard Day's Night made the Byrd's go folk rock. Rubber Soul is much more listenable than Dylan Highway 61. The Beatles were the 60's not to have one of there albums is missing the point really.
Dylan is just a terrible singer no wonder why his albums never sold that well and other artists made superior versions of his songs. On the other hand Elvis never wrote his songs but was a great singer hence you have the two most overrated artists of all time, artists who were good at one thing.
I have to say your list is again is anti Beatle and you have no arguement to say these albums are overrated. For an album to be overrated to me is to have no impact on musicians and on the public. Clearly all of the Beatles albums you listed as overrated had a clear impact on the industry of rock music, the public and most of all the musicians. As for you knocking the Beatles as musicians you are lost, Paul McCartney is one of the most versatile rock musicians of all times, Lennon played at least three instruments and Harrison played the sitar, mellotron, slide guitar and 12 string guitar all effectively and made huge impact on popularizng those intruments in rock music. As songwriters they were no greater hitsmakers in rock music than the Beatles and the vocal harmonies on Abbey Road are amongst the most coppied in rock music. The Beatles wanted to be big and what they became is the most influential act ever in rock music.
Are you serious Captain Beefhart and Nico over John Lennnon as a vocalist I don't mean to be nasty. Have you heard of songs like A Day in the Life or the primal vocals of Yer Blues.