Scaruffi Quotes That Have Made Me Laugh Out Loud (Quite Literally)

Tags: 

Scaruffi's sarcastic and cynical approach to some artists, albums & places is just pure comedy considering how devoid of humour his usual writing is, and makes for some great reading.

No offence intended if you like said bands.

If you find any good ones, please suggest.

(On Madonna's Hard Candy Album)

Hard Candy (2008), yet another terrible album, used an impressive cast of producers (Nate "Danja" Hills, Timbaland, Justin Timberlake, Pharrell Williams) to craft predictable and trivial dance numbers such as Four Minutes. About to turn 50, Madonna is turning into one ugly dumb middle-age woman who is still desperate for sex, perhaps because her private life was such a failure.

(On Madonna's American Life Album)

American Life (Warner, 2003) manages to be even worse (more trivial, incoherent, incohesive, amateurish) than its predecessor, an almost impossible feat. The bouncy techno of Nobody Knows Me and Hollywood is pure wishful thinking, and Madonna's adult persona, the one displayed in an endless sequence of lullaby-ballads (Intervention, Love Profusion, X-Static Process), as well as in the pathetic gospel of Nothing Fails, is a garbage can of cliches.

(On Britney Spears, spanning her entire profile)

If you like the Beatles, then Louisian-born teen-idol Britney Spears is a milestone in popular music. If you think the Beatles were the biggest rip-off of all times, then... they were the second biggest. The biggest is Britney Spears, a trivial singer and a trivial dancer dancer who has mastered the art of copying the trends, although a product on which the music industry has lavished millions of dollars to create an overnight sensation. And an overnight sensation she became when (barely 18) she debuted with Baby One More Time, a catchy refrain propelled by martial hip-hop beats (courtesy of Max Martin, the same man behind the music of the Backstreet Boys). The album Baby One More Time (Jive, 1999) will sell ten million copies in just one year. The production work was certainly state-of-the-art, but what "sold" was her image of malicious (quasi-nymphomaniac) teenager and her throaty "oh baaaby".
She became the youngest artist ever to top the charts for both singles and albums. Teenagers around the world went nuts, the same way their grandfathers had done when the Beatles first uttered "yeah yeah yeah". The media scrutinized her private life and websites overflew with sexy photos of Britney's tits and Britney's thighs.

Not having left much to uncover, Spears returned with an equally terrible collection, Oops (Jive, 2000), that includes the new hit, the equally catchy, romantic and danceable Oops I Did It Again. But the fans remained faithful: this one sold "only" eight million copies in one year.

Britney (2001) and In the Zone (2003) mainly capitalized on her sexy persona (the "grown up" version of Britney the poster girl). Spears was slowly evolving towards a Madonna-lookalike and soundalike.

Her behavior too changed dramatically: after promising to remain a virgin until she got married, she married at 22 and then divorced a few days later. Then she got married for real, gave birth to two children, and divorced again after just three years. Her escapades became much more popular than her music, whether posing half-naked for a weekly magazine or being photographed with no underwear. For millions of middle-class families, she became the poster girl of everything that was wrong with the middle-class kids of her generation.

In 2007 she returned to live shows after a three-year hiatus, and she launched a new hit, Gimme More, but she caused a furor when she appeared (overweight, out of shape and unprepared) in a tight bikini at an MTV show.

(On The Backstreet Boys' three most recent albums.)

The quintet's Millennium (Jive, 1999) sold 12 million copies in one year (I Want It That Way , Larger Than Life, I'll Never Break Your Heart). That's about all there is to say about their music. They share with the Beatles the mass hysteria of their fans and the complete lack of originality in their music.

It would be hard to make a more predictable album than Black & Blue (Jive, 2000) and its first single Shape Of My Heart. The childish celebration of Everyone is the closest they get to producing some music.

Never Gone (2005) was one of the least imaginative albums of tedious ballads ever assembled.

(On The Spice Girls)

The British female quintet Spice Girls were the most famous musical act in their country throughout the second half of the 1990s, starting with the hit Wannabe (1996) and selling more than 20 million copies of the awful albums Spice (1996) and Spiceworld (1997). The Spice Girls were as silly as the Beatles, and as popular in the British tabloids, but never learned how to write a decent melody.

(On The Pyramids)

Generally speaking, the pyramids rank among the most overrated attractions in the world, mainly because the Greks included them in the "seven wonders of the world". The truth is that it is not terribly difficult to build a pyramid if you can use the free labor of thousands of slaves. Ultimately, it is just a pile of rocks.

(On Things That Annoyed Mr. Scaruffi In The USA)

# Waiters are hysterical about cleaning your table even before you finished eating
# Lots of homeless beggars, more than in any other Western country.
# Obesity
# People do not wash their hands before eating and often suck their fingers when finished eating (when you use the utensils at an all-you-can-eat buffet, those utensils have been used by countless people who did not wash their hands), a puzzling behavior by people who are obsessed with deodorants and showers and flossing

(On Afghanistan)

Kabul is still an awful place to live in (Rumsfeld's family should be relocated to Kabul, so he would stop claiming that life in Kabul improves by the day).

(On Celine Dion)


Celine Dion is successful precisely because her voice is so meaningless, possibly the least inventive and emotional of her generation.

(On The Backstreet Boys' album Never Gone)

Never Gone (2005) was one of the least imaginative albums of tedious ballads ever assembled.

(On Paula Abdul)

Dance-pop diva Paula Abdul, originally a choreographer for Michael and Janet Jackson, became first famous for her videos and singles, such as Straight Up (1988), from Forever Your Girl (1988), Opposites Attract, The Way That You Love Me (1989), but then also for being unable to sing or dance, as live shows and follow-up albums Spellbound (1991) and Head Over Heels (1995) proved Nonetheless, she (and Madonna) proved the importance of choreography for the star of the 1990s, a lesson that the generation of Britney Spears will learn well

(On Some of Travis' Albums)


The Man Who (Independiente, 1999), a best selling album in the UK, has little to commend itself. The sound is copied from late Pink Floyd and Radiohead. The catchy Why Does It Always Rain On Me is creative as anything their friend Britney Spears has done. The rest is split between trivial refrains and sleep-inducing ballads (Luv).

The Invisible Band (Independiente, 2001) is one long yawn. The potential hits are packed at the beginning (Sing, Dear Diary, Side) and they are not exactly Beethoven's Ninth. The rest is even less entertaining.

12 Memories (Epic, 2003) has even fewer potential hits (Re-Offender, the touching Something Else), but, in a rare feat of lack of imagination, it manages to ape the Beatles at their most morose (Peace the Fuck Out, Walking Down the Hill, Quicksand) and U2's tedious political sermons (Peace The Fuck Out, The Beautiful Occupation).

(On Artificial Intelligence (the film))

Artificial Intelligence (2001) is an embarassing hodgepodge of Hollywoodian stereotypes, terribly slow and lengthy, pointless and devoid of any message, although salvaged by mesmerizing visual effects.

(On Some of Stereophonics' Albums)

Language Sex Violence Other? (V2, 2005) is an insult to the intelligence of the public. Pull The Pin (2007) is an insult to their own intelligence because it is more of the same.

(On The Manic Street Preachers)

Lifeblood (Epic, 2004) continues the string of awful releases by Manic Street Preachers. This time the uninspired trio delves into old-fashioned easy-listening music, which only occasionally redeems itself from total boredom (The Love Of Richard Nixon, To Repel Ghosts, Solitude Sometimes Is).

Send Away The Tigers (2007) had even fewer interesting moments.

(On Amon Tobin's Defocus)

The apparently unassuming Defocus is actually a new kind of symphony. Tobin warps the distinctive tone of an instrument to produce a new kind of instrument, and then weaves a few of them (a bee-like violin, a distorted bass, UFO-sounding flutes) into an organic flow of sound. It is, in fact, one of the most significant innovations since Beethoven added a choir to a symphony.

(On The Rolling Stones)

While the Beatles had tea with the Queen, the Stones were pissing in public.

I wish I had been collecting my favorite quotes while reading his stuff; I've read over a thousand pages of Scaruffi material, and he has many choice quotes.

Indeed, he's certainly got a plethora of interesting texts to read, these were just a few that happened to catch my eye recently that made me laugh.

re: Paula Abdul

Dance-pop diva Paula Abdul, originally a choreographer for Michael and Janet Jackson, became first famous for her videos and singles, such as Straight Up (1988), from Forever Your Girl (1988), Opposites Attract, The Way That You Love Me (1989), but then also for being unable to sing or dance, as live shows and follow-up albums Spellbound (1991) and Head Over Heels (1995) proved Nonetheless, she (and Madonna) proved the importance of choreography for the star of the 1990s, a lesson that the generation of Britney Spears will learn well.

...on Celine Dion

Celine Dion is successful precisely because her voice is so meaningless, possibly the least inventive and emotional of her generation.

and perhaps my all time favorite, re: Backstreet Boys...this is the entire review:

Never Gone (2005) was one of the least imaginative albums of tedious ballads ever assembled.

So have I, but I must admit I don't know how I could top the Pyramids quote at least for sheer ridiculousness.

Nice list. Scaruffi says some indelible, dead-pan funny shit every now and then. Here's his reviews of some albums by Travis...

The Man Who (Independiente, 1999), a best selling album in the UK, has little to commend itself. The sound is copied from late Pink Floyd and Radiohead. The catchy Why Does It Always Rain On Me is creative as anything their friend Britney Spears has done. The rest is split between trivial refrains and sleep-inducing ballads (Luv).

The Invisible Band (Independiente, 2001) is one long yawn. The potential hits are packed at the beginning (Sing, Dear Diary, Side) and they are not exactly Beethoven's Ninth. The rest is even less entertaining.

12 Memories (Epic, 2003) has even fewer potential hits (Re-Offender, the touching Something Else), but, in a rare feat of lack of imagination, it manages to ape the Beatles at their most morose (Peace the Fuck Out, Walking Down the Hill, Quicksand) and U2's tedious political sermons (Peace The Fuck Out, The Beautiful Occupation).

All great quotes! They'll all get added :) The best has to be the Celine Dion one though.

The Britney Spears one just starts repeating itself about halfway through (os is just in the list twice). Just thought I'd point that out.

Ahh yes thanks for that, I'll change it.

Ahhh, the Madonna album:
http://www.markprindle.com/madonnaa.htm#american

"I've been writing this review site for more than seven years. I'll be the first to admit I took a couple years off in the middle there, but more or less one can kind of lie and say that I've been doing it for seven years. Lucky 13!!! Heh heh heh. Yes, and in all that time I've heard some truly horrendous, unlistenable records - records that rate at the very bottom of a metric 1-10 scale. Your Metal Machine Music, your Y Kant Tori Read -- heck, on this page alone, Madonna has scored a couple of 1s. But in all my years of reviewing - from the beginning of the 20th century clear through to the end of the 21st -- I never expected to come across an album with such a volative mixture of uncreative melody, embarrassing production and offensive, moronic lyricism that it would physically bust through the bottom of my scale and force my wife to design a graphic for "ZERO." After all, how would one go about getting a ZERO on a scale of 1 to 10? Genius that she is, Madonna has figured it out!"

LOL, harsh criticism can be great fun to read :)

this guy sure delivers some comical zingers! i have to say i liked The Man Who but hey, what he said was funny :P

LOL indeed, I certainly don't agree with a lot of what he writes, but some of it is still some funny shit :)

My Personal favourite

(On Manic Street Preachers)

Lifeblood (Epic, 2004) continues the string of awful releases by Manic Street Preachers. This time the uninspired trio delves into old-fashioned easy-listening music, which only occasionally redeems itself from total boredom (The Love Of Richard Nixon, To Repel Ghosts, Solitude Sometimes Is).

Send Away The Tigers (2007) had even fewer interesting moments.

Nice! Added.

I love it how he always takes the time to slam the Beatles while he's at it - don't wanna turn this into a debate but:

"If you like the Beatles, then Louisian-born teen-idol Britney Spears is a milestone in popular music"

Is one of the most ridiculous things on his site (is he really THAT out of touch??)

The guy reminds me of Ed Anger (the hate-filled ranting old guy from the Weekly World News) sometimes! (which is a good thing!!)

Yeah, I agree. He must have some personal beef with them, because he on numerous occasions compares them to 4/10 quality artists, despite the beatles having some 6/10s and a 7/10. However, it's still funny :P

Scaruffi has a way with well-worded spite, but IMHO none of these are as clever as this review. Then again, maybe Mr. Scaruffi has never had the same inspiration, since a search for "Federline" on his site provides no results.

This has long been one of my favorite reviews... :)

Shalom, y'all!

L. Bangs

"And although he's 'coming out like Janet's titty at the Super Bowl,' he's not nearly as shocking as he'd like to believe or as amusing as his haters would hope: he just comes across as a big boob."

Pure gold.

Thanks for posting that. Perhaps the best written negative review of an album I've ever read. Lester Bangs' amazing review of Astral Weeks may be the finest positive review I've yet come across:
http://www.maths.dundee.ac.uk/~sanderso/music/astralrev.html

Scaruffi's take on The Velvet Underground & Nico is quite good as well, not to mention some others.

For my money, Stephen Thomas Erlewine is easily the best music critic around. (Considering I have often earned my bread as a music critic, that's praise; I'm confessing he kicks my ass!)

The amount that man writes matched wieh the high quality of his prose, the sharpness of his insights, and the vast depth of his knowledge would be impressive enough. Meld that with superior taste, and wow.

He's incredibly nice, to boot!

Shalom, y'all!

L. Bangs

Nice? Have you met him, lbangs? Do tell.

I was annoyed by Mr. Erlewine's reviews of my early favorite artists at first, but after years spent surfing the All Music Guide, I've grown a much deeper appreciation for him. I'm not really familiar with enough music critics to rate them, but he certainly keeps me reading the AMG!

I've never met him, but I have corresponded with him over the years. He is incredibly kind, which I frankly find very refreshing after encountering many famed critics of music and film.

Have you read many of his jazz, blues, and country reviews? He knows his stuff. Even better, he can harness that knowledge to make creative yet apt comparisons between works of various genres in a way most of his contemporaries can only dream about.

He is also one of the few critics in the land who can write fair, observant pieces on indie rock and mainstream pop in the same week. That's much harder than it sounds.

Shalom, y'all!

L. Bangs

"Football rules. You don't go anywhere without signs of football. Just about everybody wears the shirts of their favorite champions (Ronaldinho being the favorite,followed by the various African stars). This is a big plus for me, since Italy won the last world cup, so i am technically champion of the world"

"As a general rule, French Africa has French habits: three hours of lunch break

Some more jokes from said person...

I'll add the first one, what's he talking about though?

An african country. I can't remember which one. I'll find out and reply later.

One of my favorites:

While the Beatles had tea with the Queen, the Stones were pissing in public.

(from his page on the Rolling Stones)

:) added.

Too bad Scaruffi in his notes can't admit that the Beatles had to write the Rolling Stones first major hit in England. Or Scaruffi also can't admit the Beatles had to pave the way for British Rock artists like Rolling Stones to make it in the World largest market. While the Stones were making three chord rock and roll the Beatles were paving the way for the Byrd's because of the Beatles chord progressions. Oh yeh The Stones copped the Beatles Psychedelic Style of Revolver and Sgt Pepper. Where is Scaruffi fairness?

I'm a musician and I would say the Beatles sounded different from most because of their ability of melodies, counter melodies and meshing it with chord progressions and techniques unusual for rock music. The Beatles songs don't follow the typical 3 CHORD 1-4-5 blues progressions of rock and roll. Yes they even don't follow Verse-chorus-verse progression. They used the ABBA Song form that uses no chorus. So Scaruffi can't even get that right.

You can hear the Beatles starting to get progressive early on:

The rhythm section for 'No Reply', strange drum work.
Strange key changes in 'Hold Me Tight'
The very jazzy chord work of 'Ask Me Why'
Complex three part harmonies that go beyond Barber Shop & Beach Boys type stuff: 'Paperback Writer', 'Nowhere Man'
Dorian Mode in "Don't Bother Me"
"Imitators" of the Beatles' "Tomorrow Never Knows." After all, that 1966 classic, with its psychedelic drone and recurring flatted-7th, provided a rough archetype for countless songs, including Love & Rockets' "Yin and Yang (the Flowerpot Man)," Echo & the Bunnymen's "Lips Like Sugar" and Kasabian's "Sun Rise Light Flies

LOL

On "Comets of Fire's Blue Cathedral" via http://www.scaruffi.com/vol7/cometson.html

"And they also spend more time figuring out how to end a song, so that it doesn't sound like the abrupt suspension of a carpet bombing."

"No, I did not forget these ones:

* Beatles
* Beach Boys

I just think there are a few hundreds that I should list if I list these two, and I don't have time to list them all."

On his Greatest Rock Bands Of All Times page.

Lol I'd forgotten that Pyramids quote, absolute gold.

I don't even know if it's actually funny or if I'm just crazy, but I was looking at his page for the Dresden Dolls (http://www.scaruffi.com/vol7/dresdend.html) and his summary of the compilation No, Virginia is amazing:

"No Virginia (2008) collects (terrible) rarities."

It's just... so laconically perfect.

I recommend his review of John Frusciante's To Record Only Water for Ten Days