I like Crash, but should I vote "no" since I thought Brokeback Mountain was better? Or are you just trying to ask if Crash is generally worthy of the title, not the actual best of the five nominees?
All depends on what you mean by deserving. If you mean was it the best movie nominated? No. That was "Brokeback Mountain" but if you mean if it deserved to win, I say yes. In most years it would have blown away the competition.
I hated Crash, it's one of the worst movies I've seen in recent years. It's on my Movies I Didn't like List.
GENERAL NOTE:
I ask whether Crash deserved to win or not, if it was better than the other 4 nominated films or not!
Thanks. I voted "no," then.
I like Crash, but should I vote "no" since I thought Brokeback Mountain was better? Or are you just trying to ask if Crash is generally worthy of the title, not the actual best of the five nominees?
If I could vote "no" a hundred times, I would.
All depends on what you mean by deserving. If you mean was it the best movie nominated? No. That was "Brokeback Mountain" but if you mean if it deserved to win, I say yes. In most years it would have blown away the competition.