Possible American Idol Theme Nights

Tags: 
  • These would be smart and thoughtful choices for a theme night:
  • Ray Charles
  • Madonna
  • Prince
  • Songs from Disney films
  • Otis Redding
  • Carole King
  • Paul Simon
  • These choices are not likely to happen, but would make for a great and interesting theme night:
  • R.E.M.
  • Elvis Costello
  • The Rolling Stones
  • David Bowie (or glam rock in general)
  • Sting
  • New Wave
  • The Who
  • Television Theme Songs (this would just be funny)
  • Britpop
  • Folk-Rock
  • These are never gonna happen but wouldn't it be cool to see the contestants try and interpret these themes:
  • The Clash
  • Radiohead
  • Elliott Smith
  • The White Stripes
  • The Flaming Lips
  • Indie Pop
  • Beck
  • The Smiths
  • Van Halen
Author Comments: 

Every year we're treated to an assortment of themed nights, many based on a guest judge... I'm sorry, but a night based on the songs of Olivia Newton-John? Ashford and Simpson? I love American Idol, but can they really not do any better than that? Anyway, here's some cool ideas, some of which seem possible and some of which are absolute fantasies. Basically these are all artists or genres with dozens of excellent songs that could actually be reinterpreted or reworked into the American Idol format in a fun and interesting way and would be challenging for the contestants to adapt to. (As opposed to another night of sappy unoriginal Diane Warren ballads).

Suggested Themes:

"Bluegrass Hits"
"Bjork Night"
"Sing Along to Famous Guitar Solos"
"Silence is Golden"

Great idea! A few more:

"Aretha Franklin"
"The Byrds"
"Movie Themes"
"One Hit Wonders"
"The 1920s"
"Songs That Begin With the Letter 'S'"
"Disco"
"Songs with 'la la la' Choruses"

"They Might Be Giants" is surely one to wish for.

Great list!

What about a yodeling night or a Public Enemy night?