The Best (Non-compilation, Non-reissue) Albums of 2004 (so far)--UPDATED

Tags: 
  • 1 – Madvillainy, Madvillain
  • 2 – Scissor Sisters
  • 3 – Blueberry Boat, Fiery Furnaces
  • 4 – Franz Ferdinand
  • 5 – A Foreign Sound, Caetano Veloso
  • 6 – Van Lear Rose, Loretta Lynn
  • 7 – Connected, The Foreign Exchange
  • 8 –You Are the Quarry, Morrissey
  • 9 – Talkie Walkie, Air
  • 10 – Showtime, Dizzee Rascal
  • 11 – The Funeral, Arcade Fire
  • 12 – Futureheads
  • 13 – Young Prayer, Panda Bear
  • 14 – Good News for People Who Like Bad News, Modest Mouse
  • 15 – DJ Kicks, Erlend Oye
  • 16 – C’mon Miracle, Mirah
  • 17 – A Grand Don’t Come for Free, The Streets
  • 18 – Fabulous Muscles, Xiu Xiu
  • 19 – A Ghost Is Born, Wilco
  • 20 –Sorry I Make You Lush, Wagon Christ
  • 21 – Smile, Brian Wilson
  • 22 – Blue Cathedral, Comets On Fire
  • 23 – Medulla, Bjork
  • 24 – The College Dropout, Kanye West
  • 25 – The Slow Wonder, A.C. Newman
  • 26 – Antics, Interpol
  • 27 – ONoffON, Mission of Burma
  • 28 – The Libertines

We agree on quite a few of the best albums this year. Check out my list, I'd love to hear what you have to say.

The Air album is titled "Talkie Walkie". On a trivial note: that's the actual ordering of that word sequence in France.
Great album, too.
(Misc. comments)
Am I only one who thinks "The Slow Wonder" is slightly overrated?

I would have The Walkmen's "Bows and Arrows" in the top 5.

I think A.C. Newman's album is pretty much pop genius. It's actually greater than any of the New Pornographers' efforts so far, if you ask me. So, I guess I don't really find it too overrated.

The Walkmen on the other hand...

I was looking over your profile, and I couldn't find a 2004 list. Do you have one?

I would love to see your choices.

Thanks for the correction! (Due to a boyhood fascination with walkie talkies as well as a strong desire to avoid dyslexia, it's so natural for me to say it the other way.)

The Walkmen, at this stage in their career, remind me a little of the Police: a great singles band, but with lots of atmospheric organ/guitar swirling sounds on their albums that I can't really get into . . . yet.

I loved them live, though. That whole rumpled preppy schtick is a unique style.

By the way, I'm very glad to see some love for Madvillainy here on Listology.

Very good album, there.

This is waaaay premature, but I think it may be the pinnacle of underground hip-hop. The "Exile on Main Street" or "London Calling" of the genre, if you will.