2001: Top Ten

Tags: 

Little Intro
2001 was a successful year for me and the movies. I saw 56 movies, a personal best for me. After much deliberation, I have come up with my top ten cinematic masterpieces of the year.

First Things First: Dishonorable Mentions
2001 was not all good by any strech of the imagination. There were vile, rotting, putrid masses of celluloid that deserve to be buried beneath the surface of Pluto. Here are the five films that really built up the bile:

5. Atlantis: The Lost Empire
Disney has fallen so far: sad sterotypes, terrible plot, and a boring movie. Didn't somebody see what happened to Titan AE?

4. Jurassic Park III
Stupidity taken to an entirely new level. No suspense, no terror, no fun.

3. Lost and Delirious
Hammy acting, juvenile screenplay, and tedious directing. I am convinced that this wasn't trashed only because there was a lesbian sex scene in it.

2. A.I.: Artificial Intelligence
When a director goes dark, critics fawn. Spielberg's movie is very dark, but it is also flawed. Tragically flawed. Jude Law and Haley Joel's brilliant performances could not save this mess.

1. Hearts in Atlantis
I really don't like to dwell on the negative in an article like this, so let me say that this treakily waste of brain matter made me furious. Bad child acting needs to stop. Alakina Mann and James Bentley in The Others put this talentless cast of kiddies to shame. Anthony Hopkins turns in a lackluster performance, that alone is enough to make me hate this film. Suffice to say that the best part is when the screen goes blank and you're spared more of this crap.

Good Times: The Honorable Mentions!

16. Memento
Cinematic brain candy. Very clever, extremely entertaining. Ultimately just fodder for the cinephile. Good fodder, but still, just fodder.

15. In the Bedroom
Some of the best acting of the year, controlled and nuanced directing, good script, but bad ending. At least I loved 3/4 of the movie.

14. The Princess and the Warrior
Beautifully shot, dream-like effort from very talented director Tom Tykwer. Perhaps it drags on too long, but I was riveted in certain scenes. It never ceased to startle me, but in the end it made more of a blunt impression than a lasting mark.

13. The Tailor of Panama
Very, very clever satire. I laughed out loud in certain scenes, and cringed in others. A perfect example of a movie that was WAY too smart for its own good.

12. Waking Life
Innovative, breath taking, in any other year, this exciting experiment would make the top ten. I loved the idea that a movie doesn't have to DO anything to BE something.

11. Series 7: The Contenders
I'm not sure a lot of people understood what this was a parody of. Some people said "its stupid just to parody reality shows". Others said that it didn't even make any sense as a reality show. I'm not sure people got that it wasn't just Reality TV that was being skewered. The line "everything feels like its been dipped in plastic" is explanation enough. Its a satire of our society today. Our brainless society in which murder is considered entertainment, and a pregnant women's fight to keep her baby is a sweeps stunt. Instead of letting the lessons sink in, people rushed to reject this witty caricature of our world today.
PS: The scene in which Bloody Mama's neice hugs her, then casually glances at the camera is the perfect embodiment of reality shows. They're all just trying to get their 15 minutes.

Finally, The Top Ten of 2001

10. Under the Sand
Propelled by the subtleties of the acting, and the completely thorough character development, Under the Sand plays out like an even more mature In the Bedroom. Charlotte Rampling does everything an actress can do right. Marie's grief and slow boiling insanity are so perfectly captured in this glorious actress. With a concept that screams "Lifetime Movie of the Week!", Under the Sand takes the central tragedy further inside of itself than I've ever seen. The agony of Marie's loss is profound, just like the denial she suffers is understandable. In a subtle, masterful movie, Rampling glows like a queen.

9. Sexy Beast
Heist movies suck. They are a dime a dozen nowadays. We had five in 2001 alone. That is why Sexy Beast is so refreshing. Old character types and a tired genre get reinvigorated in this dark comedy. Ben Kingsley's wonderful performance is actually not so much evil as it is violently insecure. Don Logan has so much baggage that he takes it out on everything else in the world. He's a middle management ganster, and he knows it. He's threatening, but he is also a trapped animal. He can still kill and lie, and maim and curse, but he isn't going to go past his current place in life. He has achieved all he can, now all he can do is scream impotently (and not so impotently) at the people he hates. Frustration and sexual angst fuel this villian, and he is the centerpiece in a wonderfully wicked tapestry. Now, Ben Kingsley is not the only thing in the film. Ray Winstone has a subtle and touching performance that rivals Don Logan, and Amanda Redman is a sensation as DeeDee. Her presence on the screen was just as riveting as anything else this year.

8. The Others
Such restrained horror, such a perfectly fluid film. If I had my way, no other horror movie would have opened this year. This haunted house joyride elevated the material so much, that I felt my breath taken away four or five times. The tension is built so well, that when the shocker hits, it hits extra hard. The really fascinating thing about the film is that it doesn't focus on the ghosts. Grace, the leading lady, is the focus of the screenplay. Grace's insecurities, her religious upbringing, her view of the world in black and white. All of the films parts come together to work as a near perfect whole. Also, this was Nicole's best performance this year, and it was a doozy.

7. The Royal Tenenbaums
Wes Anderson creates a little diorama world for us. His characters are detailed to the most minute degree. His story is a messy little masterpiece. His screenplay is a marvel of humour and quirkiness. The fact that most people ignored this, saying it wasn't funny, or too weird, is a tribute to the director. His film manages to be universal to cinephiles. He created a deeply personal work that matches up to our expectations. He coaxes fabulous performances out of a hodge podge cast, and creates an almost-masterpiece. That little 'almost' adds to the tragic good humour of this eccentric upheavel.
PS: I find it funny that exaggeration it ultimately what brings out the most truth in characters and situations.

6. In the Mood for Love
Has there ever been a romance in which the chemistry is so powerful in such an unconventional way? Maggie Cheung and Tony Leung, under the gifted guidance of Wong Kar-Wai, smolder with distinction. The unconsumated love affair hits harder than the agressive passion of Satine and Christian, Hedwig and Tommy, or even the devoted friendship of Our Song. Sumptuous to look at, and even more beautiful to hear, In the Mood for Love moves you like no other. The potent direction and intelligent performances match perfectly with the ingenius cinematography. If you can watch a film with the sound off and still be moved....damn.

5. Our Song
Truth in film doesn't usually do well. Naturalism hasn't caught on here in the states. Everything is stylized or artificial. Nothing seems to ring true. Nothing except Our Song. The story of a couple of weeks in three girls' lives, Our Song flows along at the pace of life. The hesitant decisions are a shared experience between the audience and the characters. We are plunked in a situation that we slowly learn about. We see the budding relationships of the young, and the pressures exerted upon every character. We see genuine emotion and artistry without any sensationalism. The ensemnle is beyond perfect, and the perhaps one day, more movies will dare to be truthful.

4. Gosford Park
Trust Altman to make a movie that fools everybody. Described as a murder mystery, Gosford Park goes far beyond that. It is a class analyzation, ensemble celebration, and witty comedy. The screenplay is the best of the year, and the witty word play is just one reason to love it. Bouncing off the walls, the characters of Gosford Park have so many secret, unsaid stories, that I would love if this film went on for hours. The tableau opens so beautifully, that I wish I could see it again for the first time.

3. The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring
Majesty. Mystery. Brilliance. Expansiveness. Scope. Emotion. Good. Evil.
Wow.

2. Moulin Rouge!
Baz Luhrmann first stripped the love story down to its Christmas tree form.
He then began to hang the tinsel. The brilliantly intricate costumes that define the characters and fit the theatrical themes. The fantastically over the top sets, with their red immersed glow. The sharp, invigorating editing that helps define the feel of the Moulin's decadence.
Then come the lights. Flamboyant music. Orgasmic coreography. A witty and entertaining screenplay.
Finally the ornaments. The innocent Christian played to perfection by Ewan McGregor. The smoldering, wilting, bubbly Satine, embodiedby the sensational Nicole Kidman. The funny/sad Harold Zidler, personified by the stunningly talented Jim Broadbent.
Baz could have made a good movie with just this, but luckily, he used his skill and remembered to plug the lights in. Everything comes together in Moulin Rouge! to make absolutely the best musical in twenty years. The ultimate movie for movie lovers. Filled to the brim with excess and wonderful things. Everything is perfect, and its all a big, fun mess.

1. Hedwig and the Angry Inch
I'm not sure I can fully explain why I love this film. I'll try to sum it up in one paragraph.
I love the way that Hedwig conveys humor, pathos, and humanity, all while remaining an iconic character. I love the way that the movie doesn't look like it was made on a shoe string budget (whcih it was). I love the way 'Wig in a Box' made me want to jump up and sing. I love the way I walked out of the theater loving movies more than I did going in. I love the way that despite all my attempts I can not describe my love for this film. I love the way that John Cameron Mitchell made the best film of the year. I love the way that despite all of its flaws, Hedwig touched me more than anything I saw this year.
I love Hedwig.

You might want to make an addendum in your comments field about which 2001 contenders you haven't seen yet.

Dan, you're absolutely right. I'll fix that soon.
Also, regarding your other post, thanks very much.

Great list, AAA! I'm glad to see you do something which I rarely do (and wish I did) which is comment on the films on my lists. That is my resolution for 2002. To actually put some words down about all of the movies that I see.

Great, great list AAA. I'm totally impressed. I can't believe you're what, 15 now? So do you already have a mortal lock on class valedictorian, or does high school bore you? I figure it's gotta be one of the two. :-) A few notes . . .

You say that "2001 was not all good by any strech of the imagination" but then in your review of Waking Life you state, "in any other year, this exciting experiment would make the top ten." That suggests to me that 2001 was indeed a good year.

Regarding Memento, could you elaborate on your comment, "ultimately just fodder for the cinephile"?

My wife gave me Moulin Rouge for Valentine's Day. I'm totally psyched to see it again.

No mention of Monster's Ball. You must have not seen it, right?

Indeed. I am still (impatiently) waiting for it to arrive in a theater near me.

Regarding the Waking Life and dishonorable mention contradiction, what the first statement was meant to say was that not every single film was great. It is an ackward phrasing, but the comments aren't meant to clash. The Waking Life comment means that the good films were really good. In any other year (in which there weren't such great films) Waking Life would find itself somewhere in the top ten. The dishonorable mentions statement means: there were many great films, but I didn't love every film I saw.
Hope I cleared that up.
As for valedictorian, I don't see that happening. I am in an honors-like Science and Technology program (even though I have no interest in those subjects), and 50% of the grades are busy work, which I tend to ignore. But hey, I'm gonna start writing reviews for my school newspaper, so there's something good.
I will definitely elaborate on Memento:
Memento leaves the viewer with a very good feeling. You've shared in a very clever trick. You feel smart watching it, it makes you feel good. But ultimately, Memento is a series of tricks. Very well done tricks, but still tricks. The screenplay is great, but there is no real deeper meat to chew on. There's the tricks of the plot, but nothing below that. Its very fun to watch, but in the end, hollow.
That's why I chose the term cinephile's fodder (not exact, but general meaning). It is a very witty, enjoyable film, but it is like smart cotton candy. Now, I loved it the first time I watched it, but I then watched it a second time. I find that if I watch a movie twice, I really learn if its a good film in my eyes.
Well, (pants), that's it. If I may say, I just recieved Cabaret on DVD for Valentine's Day, and it is still the greatest film adaptation of a musical. "Tomorrow Belongs to Me" may be the most perfect scene ever.
There, I'm done, I promise.
Thanks for the comments!
AAA (NKT)

In your 2001:Movies I've Seen list, you put Chopper and The Circle in your top tier, yet they are mysteriously missing from your top ten. Better yet your honorable mentions. What gives Nathanial?

The Circle is number 18, and Chopper ends up at 19. There are only so many spots left. Here's how my top twenty finishes up:
17. The Dish
18. The Circle
19. Chopper
20. Ghost World
I really wanted The Dish to make my top 16, but there just wasn't room.

The more I think about it, Memento could be the best film of the year. I'm blown away by that film.

That is seriously the beauty of art. People can have such different reactions. I liked Memento, but didn't love it, but opinions can differ freely. I completely respect your opinion. You've always stuck to your guns, and I respect nothing more than I respect that.
PS: Memento is a very good film, no question.

You did clear up the two apparently contradictory comments, thanks!

Regarding Memento, I'd venture that all moviemaking is a series of tricks. :-) But seriously, I can see where it could be viewed as all-gimmick-no-substance, and I've heard the criticism before that a story doesn't get better just by telling it backwards (not that that's your point here). However, to me the "deeper meat to chew on" is Memento's exploration of the unreliability/subjectivity of memory even under the best of circumstances. In this regard it works on at least two levels: the characters and the audience.

But you have an advantage on me having seen it twice. I'm totally with you on a second viewing being required to galvanize your opinions. Unfortunately, I rarely get the opportuntity, so I just have to throw my half-baked opinions around. :-)

Well, Memento is a good film, and I'm glad that its gotten the credibility that it has. Most people I know love it, and I enjoy it a lot, so I can't say that it is anywhere near a bad film.
Also, the second viewing thing helps only in some cases. Many times I know a movie is bad the first time I watch it, a second time isn't necessary.

So, isn't that DVD of Cabaret amazing?

Though it is an early DVD, it is still one of my favorites, with a beautiful transfer, sparkling soundtrack, and interesting extras. Any version shown on television just can't compete. This films demands DVD. Damn, I need to pull that out and watch it again this week!

Shalom, y'all!

L. Bangs

AAA, just a quick note to say how much I liked this list. Your writing and more importantly your thought process has improved dramatically. A very well done job and keep it up.

Wow, thanks a lot! That is very kind of you to say. This feedback means a lot to me. Especially coming from someone who's writing i respect so much.